Pipe Wrinkling During Bending on Tube Bending Machine – Causes & Solutions
A heavy steel pipe curves through a hydraulic bending machine inside a working fabrication shop.
Wrinkling mostly occurs on the inner compression side of the bend. In rare cases, wrinkles appear at the pipe end or tail of the bending arc. Principle: The metal on the inner side is compressed during bending, and excess material accumulates to form wrinkles.
Problem: No wrinkle-resistant insert (anti-wrinkle block) on the inner bend, or improper position / worn anti-wrinkle block Answer: The compressed metal on the inner side accumulates without supporting restraint, causing wrinkles directly. Solution: Install an anti-wrinkle block matched with pipe diameter and wall thickness. Adjust its position so the front cutting point aligns with the bending tangent point. Replace worn blocks. Use wear-resistant copper or alloy material for anti-wrinkle inserts.
Problem: Insufficient mandrel extension or improper mandrel position (mandrelless bending / too short mandrel) Answer: The mandrel supports the inner pipe wall. If the extension length is inadequate, the inner wall of the bend lacks support, resulting in wall collapse and material stacking wrinkles. Solution: Increase mandrel extension appropriately, extend close to the bending tangent point (do not over-extend to avoid piercing the pipe wall). Use segmented ball-head mandrels. Mandrel is mandatory for thin-wall tubes.
Problem: Too thin pipe wall, or too small relative bending radius (small R/D ratio) Answer: Smaller bending radius brings heavier compression deformation on the inner side. Thin-wall tubes are highly prone to material stacking and wrinkling. Solution: Increase bending radius if product drawing permits. If the dimension is fixed, adopt higher-strength pipe material or use mandrel + anti-wrinkle block combined process.
Problem: Excessively fast bending speed Answer: At high bending speed, the inner metal cannot flow evenly, and local material piles up instantly to form wrinkles. Solution: Reduce bending angular speed and lower the bending parameter on CNC tube bender. Use low constant speed for thin-wall pipe bending.
Problem: Insufficient clamping force of clamping die, pipe slipping Answer: The workpiece slides inside the clamping die during bending, shifting the bending tangent point and disturbing metal flow, which creates wrinkles. Solution: Raise clamping pressure moderately. Check wear of clamping die teeth. Add anti-slip texture on clamping die. Ensure the clamping die arc fully matches the outer diameter of the tube.
Problem: Improper thrust of booster die (follow die) Answer: Insufficient booster thrust cannot feed material forward for compensation and causes inner material accumulation. Excessive thrust forcibly squeezes the pipe and generates ripples. Solution: Fine-tune booster thrust according to pipe size. The thrust should only assist smooth forward sliding without overload.
Problem: Defects of raw pipe material Answer: Out-of-round pipe, uneven wall thickness, oxide scale or inconsistent material hardness leads to uneven deformation during bending and causes wrinkling. Solution: Perform incoming inspection and reject tubes with excessive ovality or large wall thickness variation. Remove burrs and oxide scale before processing. Unify annealing state of raw tubes.
Problem: Inadequate lubrication Answer: High friction between mandrel and inner pipe wall hinders metal flow, and inner material accumulates to form wrinkles. Solution: Apply dedicated tube bending oil or emulsion to fully lubricate mandrel and pipe inner surface. Select suitable lubricant for steel pipe to reduce friction.
Problem: Excessive pressure of pressure die (guide die) Answer: Over-tight pressure die locks the pipe and prevents smooth sliding, resulting in compressed material accumulation and wrinkling on inner side. Solution: Reduce pressure die pressure. Ensure the pipe can slide freely without being locked.
Problem: Mismatch between die cavity arc and pipe outer diameter nswer: Oversized die cavity creates clearance between die and pipe. The pipe loses support and wrinkles inward during bending. Solution: Machine die cavity according to actual outer diameter of pipe. Replace bending dies with precise matching size to minimize clearance.
Quick Troubleshooting Sequence for On-site Commissioning
Check wear and matching of dies (anti-wrinkle block, clamping die, pressure die)
Adjust mandrel extension length
Tune pressure die force and booster thrust
Reduce bending speed and improve lubrication
Inspect incoming pipe quality
If you have any questions regarding bending, please feel free to contact me.
Leave a Reply